Regulations

Two Rules, One Deadline: Why 'The EPA Relaxed the Rules' Could Cost You $59K a Day

Right before New Year's, the EPA eased enforcement of some deadlines in one refrigerant rule. Contractors are assuming that means the other one got relaxed too. It didn't. Here's why the difference matters.

7 min read
ByRef LeakLog Team
EPATechnology TransitionsSubpart CSubpart BenforcementR-410AAIM Actcompliance

If you've been anywhere near an HVAC trade group, supply house counter, or contractor forum in the past two weeks, you've probably heard some version of this:

"Did you hear? The EPA backed off the January 1st rules."

That statement is half true — and the half that's wrong could cost you up to $124,426 per violation per day.

Editor's note (June 16, 2026)

An earlier version of this post cited $69,733 per violation, per day. That figure was the Safe Drinking Water Act per-day maximum for penalties assessed between December 27, 2023 and January 8, 2025 (it is now $71,545) — not the Clean Air Act amount that governs AIM Act refrigerant enforcement. The correct, current figures are $59,114 per day for administrative penalties (capped at $472,901) and $124,426 per day for judicial penalties. Our June 15 settlement post explains the correction in full.

Update (September 2026)

The Subpart B "enforcement discretion" described below was a stopgap. The EPA finalized its reconsideration of the Technology Transitions rule in May 2026, and the amended 40 CFR § 84.54 took effect July 27, 2026: residential and light commercial systems built from components manufactured or imported before January 1, 2025 may still be installed, with no 2026 cutoff, and the cold-storage and remote-condensing-unit dates moved to July 27, 2026. What that rule changed — and why your Subpart C leak logs didn't move. Everything this post says about Subpart C is unchanged.

Here's what actually happened, what it means for your business, and why getting this wrong is the most expensive misunderstanding in the HVAC trade right now.

Editor's note (October 2, 2026)

This post's worked example was a 20-pound R-410A commercial rooftop unit, and its customer script said "Your rooftop units are covered." EPA's preamble places packaged rooftop units and split systems in the residential and light commercial subsector that § 84.106 exempts at any charge (89 FR 82718–82719). The example now uses a 20-pound air-cooled chiller with the same numbers, and both scripts say what the rule covers. We also corrected the record-retention line, since the appliance file is kept until three years after the appliance is retired, and narrowed the table's description of who the leak rule affects.

Editor's note (October 7, 2026)

We re-checked this post against EPA's own words. The December statement, posted on EPA's Technology Transitions rulemaking page on December 23, 2025, called enforcement of the deadlines under reconsideration "a low enforcement priority," said those deadlines remained in effect, and named no equipment; EPA has since taken it off that page. This post had described it as a promise not to enforce, listed equipment the statement never named, and went on describing the relief in the present tense. Those passages now say what EPA said and when. We also corrected the exceptions to the leak-rate calculation, the repair triggers and clock, the day count from January 1, the closing table's installation advice, and the product description, and made clear that Subpart B restricts equipment, not the refrigerant itself. The September update above leaves out two things: variable refrigerant flow systems keep their own installation dates (§ 84.54(c)(2)), and the amended rule raised the cold storage warehouse and retail food remote condensing unit limits from July 27, 2026 (to 700 and 1,400) while moving their original 150 and 300 limits to January 1, 2032. Since this post ran, EPA has proposed exempting road and intermodal container transport refrigeration units from the leak-repair rule and said it will reconsider the rest of the 2024 rule behind Subpart C; as of October 7, 2026, neither has changed Subpart C.

What the EPA Actually Did on December 23rd

On December 23, 2025 — just nine days before the January 1 deadline — the EPA posted an enforcement statement on its Technology Transitions rulemaking page about the Technology Transitions Rule (40 CFR Part 84, Subpart B), which it was reconsidering. The operative line: enforcement of "the current deadlines subject to the TT Rule Reconsideration is a low enforcement priority for the Agency." The same statement said those deadlines "remain effective until modified through this rulemaking" and that EPA "may take any action necessary to protect human health and the environment."

In plain English: while EPA rewrote those deadlines, enforcing them was a low priority — but they stayed on the books. The statement named no equipment. The deadlines then under reconsideration included the January 1, 2026 cutoff for installing residential and light commercial air conditioning and heat pump systems built from components manufactured or imported before 2025, and the 2026 limits for new retail food remote condensing units and cold storage warehouse systems (91 FR 31294–31300).

HARDI, the heating and refrigeration distribution trade association, had been pushing hard for exactly this kind of relief. Their CEO called it "welcome news for distributors and contractors going into the new year."

And it is welcome news — for that specific rule.

But here's the problem. There are two separate rules hitting on the same date, and only one of them got any relief.

The Two Rules: A Side-by-Side

This is the distinction every contractor in America needs to understand right now:

Technology Transitions (Subpart B)Leak Repair & Management (Subpart C)
What it governsWhat refrigerant you can install in new equipmentHow you must manage leaks in existing equipment
Key requirementGWP limits on new installationsLeak rate calculations, repairs, and recordkeeping for covered 15-lb+ systems
Enforcement as of Jan 1, 2026Reconsideration finalized May 2026 (see the update note above) — at the time, EPA called enforcing the deadlines under reconsideration a low priorityFully in effect — no relief, no discretion, no delay
Who it primarily affectsContractors installing new residential/commercial systemsAnyone servicing or operating covered equipment (15 lb or more, outside the residential and light commercial AC and heat pump exemption)
This Is the Dangerous Assumption

Many contractors are hearing "EPA relaxed the rules" and assuming it applies to everything. EPA's December statement covered only Subpart B deadlines it was reconsidering (rules for new equipment). Subpart C — the 15-pound leak repair, recordkeeping, and reporting requirements — has applied since January 1, 2026, and that statement did not reach it. If your tech adds refrigerant to a covered 15-lb+ system — other than right after a retrofit or a new installation, or as a qualifying seasonal variance — and no one calculates the leak rate, the system's owner or operator is out of compliance (§ 84.106(b)).

Why They're Confused — And Why It's Understandable

The confusion is understandable for a few reasons. Both rules fall under the same law (the AIM Act). Both have January 1, 2026 compliance dates. Both involve refrigerant. And the trade press coverage has been, frankly, muddled — headlines saying "EPA eases refrigerant rules" without specifying which rules.

Add in the fact that most small contractors don't track federal rulemaking (they're busy, you know, running a business), and you've got a recipe for widespread non-compliance based on misinformation.

To be crystal clear:

Subpart B (Technology Transitions) is about the future — what equipment can be manufactured, imported, sold, and installed going forward, and with which refrigerants. The EPA was reconsidering parts of this rule and said that, while that process played out, enforcing the deadlines under review was a low priority — not that it wouldn't enforce them. This is the one that got "relaxed."

Subpart C (Emissions Reduction and Reclamation) is about the present — how you manage refrigerant in the equipment that's already out there. This rule is final, published, and effective. EPA had proposed no change to it, and its December statement did not touch it. There is no grace period.

Subpart B
Some Deadlines Eased
Subpart C
Fully In Effect
0
Grace Period (Days)

What Subpart C Requires — Right Now

Since we covered this in detail over the past two weeks (Post 1, Post 2), here's the quick refresher on what's been live since January 1:

Every covered appliance with 15+ lbs of refrigerant (any regulated HFC, or a substitute with GWP > 53; the residential and light-commercial AC/heat-pump subsector, rooftop units and split systems included, is excluded under § 84.106(a)(3)(ii)) must have its full charge documented. That documentation should already exist.

Every time refrigerant is added, the owner or operator must calculate the leak rate using either the Annualizing or Rolling Average method. No exceptions except an addition made right after a retrofit or the installation of a new appliance, or one that qualifies as a seasonal variance.

If the leak rate exceeds the trigger (10% for comfort cooling, refrigerated transport, and other appliances; 20% for commercial refrigeration; 30% for industrial process), a repair must be completed within 30 days (120 if an industrial process shutdown is required), with an initial verification test in the same window and a follow-up test after it.

If total leakage hits 125% of full charge in a calendar year, the system is a chronic leaker and must be reported to EPA by March 1 of the following year.

Records must be kept for at least three years — the (l)(1) appliance file until three years after the appliance is retired.

None of this changed. None of this was softened. All of it is enforceable right now.

The Risk for Small Contractors

Here's the scenario that should keep you up at night.

Your tech goes out on a service call this week. Air-cooled chiller, 20 pounds of R-410A. The system is running warm, so the tech tops it off with 4 pounds. He writes up the invoice, lists the refrigerant quantity, and heads to the next call.

Under the old rules, that's a perfectly normal Tuesday.

Under Subpart C, that service event just triggered a mandatory leak rate calculation. Four pounds on a 20-pound system — even with the first-calculation 365-day substitution — that's a 20% rate. For comfort cooling, the threshold is 10%. The owner now has 30 days to repair the leak and verify the fix.

If that calculation never gets done, if the repair never happens, if the documentation doesn't exist — you're looking at a Subpart C violation. And if you or your tech thought "the EPA backed off," you might not realize the problem until an inspector shows up or the building owner gets audited.

Protect Yourself and Your Customers

The fastest way to avoid this scenario is to build the leak rate calculation into your standard service workflow. Every tech, every call, every time refrigerant goes in. It takes 30 seconds with the right tool. It takes a lot longer to explain to a customer why they're facing EPA fines because nobody did the math.

What to Tell Your Customers This Week

If you're the contractor who proactively reaches out to building owners and says, "Hey — you may have heard the EPA relaxed some rules. Here's what that actually means for your equipment" — you just became the most trusted vendor they have.

Here's a simple framework for the conversation:

"The EPA eased up on a deadline for installing certain new equipment. That's the news you probably heard. But the rules about maintaining the equipment you already have — the leak tracking, repair timelines, and recordkeeping — those are fully in effect. They cover refrigeration and chillers with 15 or more pounds of HFC refrigerant; rooftop units and split systems are exempt. If you have covered equipment, we need to make sure we're calculating leak rates and keeping proper records every time we add refrigerant."

That's a 30-second conversation that positions you as the expert, protects your customer, and opens the door to a compliance-focused maintenance agreement.

The contractor who clears up this confusion for building owners this week wins the compliance conversation for the next decade.

What to Tell Your Techs Today

Even simpler:

"The deadline for installing new residential and light-commercial systems built from pre-2025 R-410A equipment got relaxed. The rule about tracking refrigerant in existing systems did not. Every time you add refrigerant to a covered system with 15 or more pounds, record the amount and the date, and the leak rate has to be calculated — skipped only for a charge added right after a retrofit or a new installation, or a qualifying seasonal variance (§ 84.106(b)). The rule doesn't cover residential and light-commercial AC and heat pumps — rooftop units and split systems included — or systems running solely on an ozone-depleting refrigerant (§ 84.106(a)(3)). Starting now."

Print that out. Tape it in the truck. Make it part of your Monday morning huddle.

The Bottom Line

Two rules. Same law. Same deadline. Very different enforcement status.

RuleStatusYour Action
Subpart B — Technology TransitionsReconsideration finalized May 2026; amended § 84.54 effective July 27, 2026 — see noteStay informed; residential and light commercial systems whose specified components were all made or imported before 2025 can be installed again (§ 84.54(c)(1); VRF has its own dates)
Subpart C — Leak Repair & ManagementFully in effectCalculate leak rates, document everything, repair when thresholds are exceeded

The industry will eventually sort out the Technology Transitions timeline. Supply chains will adjust. Equipment inventories will clear. That's a 2026-2027 story that will unfold over months.

But Subpart C compliance? That started January 1. The clock is running. And "I heard the EPA backed off" isn't a defense. If you need every Subpart C threshold and deadline in one place, the complete field reference is built for the truck.


Next Monday, we're covering the five most common documentation mistakes contractors are already making in Week 1 — and exactly how to fix them before they become audit liabilities. See you January 12th.

Subpart C Is Live. Are You Ready?

Ref LeakLog logs each refrigerant addition, calculates the leak rate on the method you choose, tracks the repair and verification tests a threshold crossing triggers, and prints each appliance's records as a PDF. Built for the contractors who can't afford to get this wrong.

Start Your Free Trial

Or see it live in the demo first — no signup needed.

Keep Reading

Stop Guessing. Start Tracking.

Join contractors across the country who use Ref LeakLog to automate EPA compliance and protect their business.