A Leak Rate Just Came Back Hot. Now What? The Complete Repair Workflow Under Subpart C
Your tech calculated a leak rate above the threshold. The 30-day clock is running. Here's the step-by-step workflow — from detection through repair, verification testing, and what happens if the fix doesn't hold.
You followed the process. Your tech weighed the refrigerant, recorded the exact quantity, and calculated the leak rate before leaving the site. The number came back above the threshold.
Now what?
This is the moment where compliance shifts from documentation to action — and where the regulation gets specific about what must happen, in what order, and by when. If you've been following along with this series (the 15-pound rule, how to calculate leak rates, Subpart B vs. C confusion, documentation mistakes), your records are solid. This post is about what happens next.
Let's walk the entire workflow, step by step, using a real-world scenario.
The worked example in this post originally used a 22-pound R-410A rooftop unit at a strip mall as a covered appliance. EPA's preamble places packaged rooftop units in the residential and light commercial subsector that § 84.106 exempts at any charge, and says the exemption does not apply to chillers (89 FR 82718–82719). The example now uses an air-cooled chiller, with the same refrigerant, charge, dates, and numbers. Re-checking the rest of the post against the rule text, we also corrected what the 30-day repair requires (repairs that bring the leak rate below the threshold, not every leak), how a repair-deadline extension works, and when the follow-up verification test is due if the appliance was evacuated for the repair.
The worked example applied the first-calculation substitution in § 84.106(b)(1) to a unit with no addition "since Subpart C started". EPA's preamble limits that: the method "is only allowed when previous records are absent" (89 FR 82724). If you have records of additions before 2026, use them. The example now says the unit had no earlier addition on record. A full re-check of the post the same day also corrected: the coverage test now includes the refrigerant criteria and the ozone-depleting exclusion; the verification-test and repair records now list what § 84.106(l)(2), (l)(5) and (l)(7) require; and the full-charge record is kept until three years after the appliance is retired.
The Scenario
Tuesday, January 20. Your tech is on a service call at a dental office in your area. Its air-cooled chiller — a 22-pound R-410A system providing comfort cooling for the practice — is running warm. The tech weighs in 4 pounds of refrigerant.
He pulls the service history (full charge: 22 lbs, last addition: none on record, so this is the first calculation). Using the Annualizing method with the 365-day substitution for a first calculation with no earlier records (§ 84.106(b)(1); 89 FR 82724):
(4 ÷ 22) × (365 ÷ 365) × 100 = 18.2%
The equipment category is comfort cooling. The threshold is 10%.
The leak rate is 18.2%. The threshold has been exceeded.
A 30-day clock just started.
Step 1: Identify and Repair the Leak (Days 1–30)
The regulation is clear: once refrigerant is added and the calculated leak rate exceeds the applicable threshold, the owner or operator must identify and repair leaks within 30 days (or 120 days if an industrial process shutdown is required), and the repairs must bring the leak rate below that threshold (§ 84.106(d)).
A few critical details here:
The clock starts when the refrigerant is added. Not when the office processes the ticket. Not when the building owner gets the report. The day the tech tops off the system and the calculation exceeds the threshold is the day the 30 days count from. In our scenario that's January 20, so the deadline is February 19.
The repair must be done by a certified technician. All repairs under Subpart C must be conducted by a technician with EPA Section 608 certification (§ 84.106(c)(1); the leak inspection that finds the leak must also be by a certified technician — § 84.106(d)(1)). This is the same certification your techs already hold — but it's worth confirming, because it's a separately citable violation if the person doing the repair isn't certified.
The repairs have to bring the leak rate below the threshold. That is the rule's standard: leaks repaired "such that the leak rate … is brought below the applicable leak rate," confirmed by the calculation at the next refrigerant addition (§ 84.106(d)(2)). So fixing only the obvious leak may not be enough. The leak inspection that finds them must cover all visible and accessible components, with the exceptions the rule lists (§ 84.106(d)(1), (g)(3)).
The 30-day window is for everything: finding the leak, repairing it, and completing the initial verification test. Don't spend 25 days chasing the leak source and then realize you still need to verify the repair.
Not 30 business days. Not 30 weekdays. Calendar days. If the refrigerant went in on January 20, the repair and initial verification test must be completed by February 19. Weekends, holidays, and your tech's vacation don't extend the deadline. To see every date this clock produces for your own exceedance — repair, both verification tests, the extension cap, and the inspection schedule — use the free repair deadline calculator.
For our dental office chiller, the most likely culprits on a unit this size: Schrader valve cores, flare connections, service valves, and the condensing coil — especially if the unit has been up on the roof for a few years taking weather. Your tech should be doing a systematic inspection with an electronic leak detector and/or UV dye, documenting every component checked and what was found.
Step 2: Initial Verification Test (Within the 30-Day Window)
Once the repair is complete, you can't just walk away. The regulation requires an initial verification test to confirm the repair actually stopped the leak (§ 84.106(e)). Both tests are broken down field by field in the verification-test walkthrough — including the sequencing rule below, which is the one shops break most often.
The initial verification test must be performed before any additional refrigerant is added to the appliance. This is key — you repair the leak, then you verify the repair under the existing conditions. You don't recharge first and then test.
What counts as a verification test? The regulation doesn't specify a single method, but the test must demonstrate that the repaired leak(s) are no longer leaking. Common approaches include standing pressure tests, electronic leak detection at the repair site, and nitrogen pressure decay testing. The method should be appropriate for the type of leak and the repair performed, and the results must be documented.
Your records need to show: the date of the verification test, the appliance's location, the location of each repaired leak tested, the method used, and the result (§ 84.106(l)(7)). A passing note like "verified — no leak detected at flare connection using electronic detector, standing pressure held for 15 minutes" is the kind of documentation that makes an auditor's day. "Tested good" does not.
Step 3: Follow-Up Verification Test (Within 10 Days)
After the initial verification test passes, there's one more step: a follow-up verification test, which must be conducted after the appliance has returned to normal operating characteristics and conditions (§ 84.106(e)).
The follow-up test confirms that the repair holds under real-world operating conditions — thermal cycling, vibration, pressure changes, and everything else a running system experiences. A repair might pass a static pressure test but fail once the compressor cycles and the unit goes through its normal temperature and pressure swings.
The regulation requires this follow-up test within 10 days of the successful initial verification test — or, if the system (or the isolated component) was evacuated for the repair, within 10 days of its returning to normal operating characteristics and conditions (§ 84.106(e)(2)). Plan on the earlier date.
There is no charge-size exemption here, and it is worth being explicit about that because the old Part 82 rules trained people to expect one. § 84.106(e) says the owner or operator "must conduct both initial and follow-up verification tests on each leak that was repaired under paragraph (d)" — no pound threshold, no gradation. If § 84.106 covers the appliance at all — 15 pounds or more of a refrigerant containing a listed HFC (or a substitute with a GWP above 53), not solely an ozone-depleting refrigerant such as R-22, and not in the exempt residential and light commercial AC and heat pump subsector, which takes in rooftop units and split systems (§ 84.106(a); 89 FR 82718–82719) — both tests are mandatory on every repaired leak. Our 22-pound chiller gets exactly the same two tests a 500-pound rack gets.
Here's the timeline so far for our dental office unit:
| Step | Action | Deadline |
|---|---|---|
| Day 0 (Jan 20) | Refrigerant added, leak rate calculated at 18.2% | — |
| Days 1–30 (by Feb 19) | Identify leak, complete repair, pass initial verification test | 30 calendar days from service |
| Within 10 days of initial test (or of normal operation, if evacuated) | Follow-up verification test under normal operating conditions | 10 days after the successful initial test — or, if the system was evacuated for the repair, 10 days after it reaches normal operating characteristics and conditions |
Step 4: Ongoing Leak Inspections
Here's the part most contractors don't realize: a successful repair doesn't end your obligations. Once an appliance has exceeded the applicable leak rate, it enters a mandatory inspection schedule that continues until the system demonstrates it's consistently below the threshold (§ 84.106(g)).
The inspection frequency depends on system size and type:
| System Category | Charge Size | Inspection Frequency | Until… |
|---|---|---|---|
| Commercial refrigeration / Industrial process | 500+ lbs | Every 3 months (quarterly) | Below threshold for 4 consecutive quarters |
| Commercial refrigeration / Industrial process | 15–499 lbs | Once per year (annually) | Below threshold for one year |
| Comfort cooling and all other covered appliances | Any charge (15+ lbs) | Once per year (annually) | Below threshold for one year |
For our 22-pound chiller, this means an annual leak inspection is required until the leak-rate calculations show the system has stayed below 10% for a full year after the successful follow-up verification test (§ 84.106(g)(1)(iii)). The inspection must cover all visible and accessible components and be conducted by a Section 608-certified technician.
This is where the repair creates a follow-on service obligation. If you're the contractor who did the repair, this is an opportunity to set up ongoing monitoring. If you're not, the building owner still needs to ensure it happens — and documenting that you informed them of this requirement protects both parties.
Ongoing quarterly or annual inspections are not required for systems (or portions of systems) that are continuously monitored by an automatic leak detection system, as long as that system is audited or calibrated annually and meets the requirements of § 84.108 — the automatic leak detection rule. For most small contractors, this applies to larger commercial refrigeration installations, not a small chiller like the one in our scenario.
The Branching Path: What Happens When the Repair Fails
Everything above assumes the repair works. But what if it doesn't? What if the initial verification test fails, or the follow-up test shows the leak is back?
This is where the regulation creates a branching decision tree, and the stakes get higher.
Path A: Retry Within the 30-Day Window
If the initial verification test fails, you can make additional repairs and retest — as long as you're still within the original 30-day window. There's no limit on the number of repair attempts within that window. You can repair, test, fail, repair again, test again, as many times as you can fit in 30 days.
The key constraint is time. Day 30 — February 19 here — is a hard boundary. If you're on Day 28 and the second repair attempt also failed, you have two days to get it right or you're moving to Path B.
Path B: Retrofit or Retirement Plan
If repairs fail to bring the leak rate below the applicable threshold, the owner or operator must create a retrofit or retirement plan within 30 days of determining that the appliance still leaks above the threshold after the required repairs and verification tests (§ 84.106(h)(1)(iii)). If you decide up front to retrofit or retire instead of repairing — or take no action at all — the 30 days run from the exceedance itself (§ 84.106(h)(1)(i)–(ii)).
Let's be precise about what this means:
Retrofit means converting the appliance to a different refrigerant (§ 84.102). The plan must give the new refrigerant's type and full charge and an itemized procedure for the conversion — what changes are needed for compatibility with the new refrigerant, what components need replacement — plus a completion schedule. All identified leaks must be repaired as part of any retrofit under the plan (§ 84.106(h)(4)).
Retirement means recovering the refrigerant and disassembling or disabling the circuit so the appliance can never run again (§ 84.102) — not just switching it off. The plan must say what happens to the recovered refrigerant and to the appliance itself, and give a completion schedule of no more than one year (§ 84.106(h)(2)(v)–(vii)). Whether you replace the unit is your business decision, not a plan element.
The plan must meet these requirements:
- Signed by an authorized company official
- Dated
- Accessible at the site of the appliance (paper or electronic)
- Available for EPA inspection upon request
- Completed within one year of the plan's date
Per § 84.106(h)(2), the plan must contain, at a minimum: (1) identification and location of the appliance; (2) the type and full charge of the refrigerant it uses now; (3) if retrofitting, the type and full charge of the refrigerant it will be converted to; (4) if retrofitting, an itemized conversion procedure, including the changes needed for compatibility with the new refrigerant; (5) a plan for the disposition of the recovered refrigerant; (6) if retiring, a plan for the disposition of the appliance; and (7) a schedule, not to exceed one year, for completing the retrofit or retirement. Separately, all identified leaks must be repaired as part of any retrofit under the plan (§ 84.106(h)(4)).
For our dental office scenario, a retrofit or retirement plan on a 22-pound chiller probably means replacement. A 22-pound comfort cooling system with a leak that can't be repaired within 30 days is likely at end-of-life. The building owner needs to know this, and they need to know it early — not on Day 29 when the clock is almost up.
Path C: Extension Requests
(For industrial process refrigeration, the base window is already 120 days when a process shutdown is required to make the repair — § 84.106(d). That is the deadline, not an extension, and no request is filed for it.)
In certain cases, the 30-day repair deadline can be extended — but the owner or operator has to meet every requirement in § 84.106(f)(1) through (4):
- Components unavailable: If parts that must be replaced aren't available within 30 days, additional time runs up to 30 days after they are delivered, but not past 180 days (or 270 days if an industrial process shutdown is required) from the date the appliance exceeded the leak rate.
- Regulatory conflict: If other applicable federal, state, local, or Tribal regulations make the repair within 30 days impossible, additional time is permitted to the extent needed to comply with them.
Either way, the extension is not automatic. Leaks the technician identified as significantly contributing to the exceedance that don't need the extra time must still be repaired and verified within the original 30 days ((f)(2)); the owner or operator must document all repair efforts and why the rest couldn't be finished in time ((f)(3)); and the owner or operator must request the extension from EPA electronically within 30 days of the exceedance (or 120 days if an industrial process shutdown is required), signed by an authorized company official ((f)(4)). The request is considered approved unless EPA says otherwise.
Note what is not a valid reason for extension: "I couldn't find a certified technician." That's not an acceptable basis for delay. Schedule accordingly.
The Complete Decision Tree
Here's the full workflow in one view:
| Stage | Action | Timeline | If It Fails… |
|---|---|---|---|
| Detection | Leak rate calculated above threshold | Day 0 (service date) | — |
| Repair | Identify leaks; repair them to bring the rate below the threshold | Within 30 days | Retry or move to Plan B |
| Initial Verification | Test repair before recharging | Within the 30-day window | Repair again and retest |
| Follow-Up Verification | Test under normal operation | Within 10 days of initial test (or of reaching normal operating characteristics and conditions, if evacuated for the repair) | Repair again or Plan B |
| Ongoing Inspections | Periodic leak inspections | Quarterly (commercial refrigeration / industrial process, 500+ lbs) or annual (everything else) | Continues until clean |
| Plan B | Retrofit or retirement plan | Within 30 days of the failed repair/verification — or of the exceedance, if you elect not to repair | Must complete within 1 year |
What This Means for You as the Contractor
Here's the reality check. Subpart C puts the legal obligations on the owner or operator of the equipment — typically the building owner or property manager. But the contractor is the one in the field doing the work, generating the documentation, and making the recommendations. (And not only as a courtesy: whoever adds the refrigerant, inspects for leaks, or runs a verification test must hand the owner the documentation for it — § 84.106(b), (l)(4), (l)(5), (l)(7).)
If you're a small HVAC contractor servicing commercial buildings, your role in this workflow is critical at every step:
At detection: You're calculating the leak rate. You're the one who knows the number exceeded the threshold. Communicate it clearly and in writing to the building owner, along with the 30-day repair requirement. Don't assume they'll figure it out.
At repair: You're performing the repair and the verification tests. Document everything — the leak location, the repair performed, the test method, the result. This documentation protects the building owner and you.
At the decision point: If the repair fails, the building owner needs to know their options immediately. Be the contractor who lays out the paths clearly: retry the repair, plan a retrofit, or plan a replacement. Don't wait until Day 28 to have this conversation. If you suspect the repair won't hold — age of the equipment, condition of the coils, history of prior leaks — say so on Day 1.
For ongoing inspections: Offer an annual inspection service specifically for systems that have triggered threshold exceedances. This is a new revenue line item that didn't exist a month ago, and the regulation creates the demand for it.
The 30-day repair clock is the building owner's obligation. The 30-day repair clock is your opportunity. The contractor who manages this workflow proactively — communicating clearly, documenting thoroughly, and offering the next step before the customer asks — becomes irreplaceable.
The Records You Need for Every Repair
Before we wrap up, here's the documentation checklist for every repair triggered by a threshold exceedance. All records must be retained for at least three years:
- Appliance identity and location
- Date refrigerant was added, the amount and type added, the name of the person who added it, and the leak rate calculation (showing it exceeded the threshold)
- Leak rate value and method used (Annualizing or Rolling Average)
- Full charge value used in the calculation
- Equipment category and applicable threshold
- Date(s) of leak inspection, method(s) used, locations checked, and a certification that all visible and accessible parts were inspected
- Leak location(s) identified
- Description of repair(s) performed, date(s) completed, and the name of the person who performed them
- Initial verification test: date, location of each repaired leak tested, method, and result
- Follow-up verification test: date, location of each repaired leak tested, method, and result
- Communication to owner/operator documenting the exceedance and repair requirement
- If applicable: retrofit or retirement plan with all required elements
- If applicable: extension request documentation
That's a lot of fields. It's also exactly what an EPA inspector will ask for. Having all of it in one place, organized per-appliance, is the difference between a routine audit and a nightmare.
Next Monday, we're shifting gears to talk about what Subpart C means for the conversations you're having with building owners — how to explain the new requirements, frame the costs, and turn compliance into a competitive advantage. See you January 26th.
Keep Going: The 30-Day Clock Series
This walkthrough anchors our repair-deadline coverage. When the standard path doesn't fit, these are the exits:
- The verification test is the only thing that closes a repair — §84.106(e): both tests, the 10-day follow-up window, and why that date anchors three separate clocks.
- Can't repair in 30 days? The extension you file with the EPA — §84.106(f), step by step, before the clock runs out.
- Repairs won't fix it? The retrofit-or-retirement plan — 30 days to write the §84.106(h) plan, one year to finish it.
- Automatic leak detection on big systems — §84.108's monitoring mandate and how it changes the inspection obligations that follow a repair.
- The leak-inspection schedule after an exceedance — §84.106(g): quarterly or annual, when the clock starts, and how the appliance earns its way off the schedule.
And when you need every threshold, deadline, and requirement in one place, bookmark the complete Subpart C field reference.
Manage the Entire Repair Workflow in One Place
Ref LeakLog tracks every step: from threshold detection through repair scheduling, verification testing, and ongoing inspections. Automated alerts make sure no deadline gets missed — even when you're running three trucks across 40 customer sites.
Start Your Free TrialOr see it live in the demo first — no signup needed.