Regulations

Wait — Is That System Even Covered? The Residential Exemption That's Confusing Everyone

Subpart C's leak-repair rules exempt residential and light commercial AC and heat pumps at any charge. EPA's preamble says that exemption follows the kind of equipment — packaged rooftop units and split systems on commercial buildings included. Chillers holding 15 lbs or more of a refrigerant containing a listed HFC are covered. Here's where EPA drew the line.

8 min read
ByRef LeakLog Team
residential exemptionlight commercialcomfort coolingSubpart CEPAcoverageequipment categoriescompliance

Over the past seven weeks, we've covered the full scope of Subpart C: the 15-pound threshold, leak rate calculations, documentation standards, repair workflows, and the 125% chronic leaker rule — all condensed into the complete field reference.

Throughout all of it, we've been referencing an exemption that's buried in the regulation — and it's the detail generating the most confusion in the field right now.

The question we hear every week: "Does this apply to the systems I service?"

For most air conditioning, the answer is no — and the exemption reaches further than many contractors assume. The covered work sits in refrigeration, chillers, and process cooling.

Editor's note (October 2, 2026)

An earlier version of this post said packaged rooftop units, commercial split systems, and commercial heat pumps on commercial buildings are covered at a 10% leak rate, and offered a test based on equipment size and building type. That was wrong. In the preamble to the 2024 rule, EPA says the exemption follows the kind of appliance, names packaged rooftop units and split systems among the exempt equipment, and declined to cover light commercial rooftop systems over five pounds (89 FR 82718–82719). The sections on where the line falls are rewritten below, and the refrigerant test now reads as the rule does: any refrigerant containing a listed HFC is in, and the GWP-above-53 test is for substitutes.

Editor's note (October 6, 2026)

The October 2 version's summary lines said simply that chillers are covered. Not every chiller is: the rule turns on the refrigerant, and R-1234ze(E), R-1233zd(E) and R-514A chillers are outside both leak-repair rules. The summary lines, the refrigerant test and the field flowchart now say so (the flowchart had no branch for those refrigerants), and the post links the chiller list, refrigerant by refrigerant.

The Exemption, In Plain English

Section 84.106(a)(3)(ii) exempts refrigerant-containing appliances used for the residential and light commercial air conditioning and heat pump subsector from all of the leak-repair requirements in § 84.106 — whatever the charge size.

That means: no leak rate calculations, no 30-day repair clock, no chronic leaker tracking, no § 84.106 recordkeeping. For systems in this subsector, the leak-repair section of Subpart C simply does not apply. (Other parts of Subpart C still bind the people doing the work: recovered refrigerant can't be sold to a new owner for reuse unless it has been reclaimed (§ 84.104(a)), and from January 1, 2028 the disposable-cylinder requirements in § 84.116 don't depend on the appliance either.)

Exempt
Rooftop units and split systems
Exempt
Heat pumps, PTACs, mini-splits
Covered at 15+ lbs
Chillers holding a listed HFC

Why the "Comfort Cooling" Definition Misleads

Subpart C also defines a category called comfort cooling: appliances used for air conditioning "to provide cooling in order to control heat and/or humidity in occupied facilities including but not limited to residential, office, and commercial buildings." It continues: "Comfort cooling appliances include but are not limited to chillers, commercial split systems, dual-function heat pumps, and packaged roof-top units" (§ 84.102).

Read alone, that sounds like every rooftop unit is in. It isn't. The definition tells you which threshold applies to a comfort-cooling appliance that is covered — 10% (§ 84.106(c)(2)(iii)). Whether the appliance is covered at all is decided first, by the exemption, and most of the equipment that definition names — rooftop units, split systems, heat pumps — sits inside the exempt subsector. The chiller doesn't. (Once an appliance is covered, the next question is which of the three § 84.102 categories it belongs to: a walk-in or a process chiller on the same site is judged at 20% or 30%.)

The Source of the Confusion

The comfort cooling definition names rooftop units and split systems; the exemption removes the subsector those units belong to. Read only the definition and everything looks covered. Read the exemption alongside EPA's own description of it, and most air conditioning is out — chillers are what remain.

Where EPA Drew the Line

The rule text doesn't define "residential and light commercial." EPA addressed it in the preamble to the 2024 rule, and it was more specific than most contractors realize:

  • It follows the kind of appliance. EPA says it is "using the terminology developed by SNAP" for the subsector, and that "the exemption applies to the categories of refrigerant-containing appliances used at these premises" (89 FR 82717–82718). It frames those categories around equipment that cools "individual rooms, single-family homes, and small commercial buildings," and lists "some rooftop air conditioning" among them — without saying which rooftop units fall outside (89 FR 82717).
  • Those categories include rooftop units and split systems. The SNAP end-use EPA adopts "includes equipment that cools enclosed spaces in households and commercial premises (excluding chillers)": window units, PTACs, portable units, ducted central air conditioners, mini- and multi-splits, packaged rooftop units, and water-source and ground-source heat pumps (89 FR 82718). EPA adds that an air conditioner at a light commercial building "would most likely be a rooftop AC unit," and names single packaged units and split-system central air conditioners and heat pumps as exempt.
  • No capacity cutoff. Commenters asked EPA to define light commercial as below 65,000 Btu/h; EPA declined (89 FR 82718). Another asked EPA to cover light commercial rooftop systems over five pounds; EPA declined that too (89 FR 82719).
  • Chillers are not exempt. "EPA clarifies that the exemption does not apply to a chiller" (89 FR 82718). The difference EPA points to: rooftop units, splits, and heat pumps condition the air directly, while a chiller cools water that is then used to condition the air.

Exempt, at any charge size

Residential split systems and heat pumps. The 2-, 3-, and 5-ton splits you install in houses.

Window, portable, and through-the-wall units, and PTACs. All named in EPA's description of the subsector.

Packaged rooftop units and single packaged units. Including the ones on commercial buildings. EPA calls the rooftop unit "one type of light commercial air conditioning" (89 FR 82718).

Split-system central air conditioners and heat pumps. Commercial splits included — EPA's description of the subsector lists "ducted unitary splits" alongside mini-splits.

Mini-splits and multi-splits, and water-source and ground-source heat pumps.

Covered

Chillers used for comfort cooling. At 15 pounds or more of a covered refrigerant, the 10% threshold applies (§ 84.106(c)(2)(iii)). Which chiller refrigerants are covered isn't obvious — R-513A and R-515B chillers are, R-1234ze(E), R-1233zd(E) and R-514A chillers aren't: the chiller list, refrigerant by refrigerant.

A supermarket refrigeration rack that also provides comfort cooling. EPA says it "would not be exempt" (89 FR 82718).

Everything that isn't air conditioning. Walk-ins, reach-ins, display cases, and racks in restaurants and stores (commercial refrigeration, 20%), industrial process refrigeration (30%), refrigerated transport and other appliances (10%) — at 15 pounds or more. If you service food businesses, start with the walk-in rules.

Not settled

VRF systems. The 2024 preamble puts VRF inside the exempt subsector and declined to carve it out (89 FR 82719). EPA's January 2026 leak-repair fact sheet says "certain variable refrigerant flow systems are covered under their own subsectors." Neither is the rule text, and they disagree — so for a large VRF system, keeping the leak-rate records is the cautious choice until EPA reconciles them.

Rooftop units serving a large building. EPA's examples center on small commercial buildings, and the rooftop-unit description it cites notes that RTUs "can also be set up in an array to provide cooling or heating throughout a larger commercial establishment such as a department store or supermarket" (89 FR 82718, footnote 63). EPA didn't say whether those arrays are in the subsector; it did say "some but not all supermarket air conditioning systems" are. For a large-building array, keeping the records is the cautious choice.

A rooftop unit that mostly serves a process. § 84.102 treats an appliance used for both process refrigeration and other applications as industrial process refrigeration "if 50 percent or more of its operating capacity is used for industrial process refrigeration." The preamble doesn't discuss rooftop units in that role. If a unit exists mainly to cool a process area rather than people, treat it as covered.

Six Scenarios

ScenarioClassificationWhy
3-ton split system in a single-family homeExemptResidential split system
5-ton packaged rooftop unit on a strip-mall storefrontExemptEPA: the rooftop unit is "one type of light commercial air conditioning"
2-ton mini-split in a dental officeExemptMini-splits are in the subsector
7.5-ton rooftop unit on a churchExemptA light commercial rooftop unit; EPA set no capacity cutoff
Air-cooled R-410A chiller holding 15+ lb, serving an office buildingCovered, 10%"The exemption does not apply to a chiller"
Supermarket rack that also cools the sales floorCoveredEPA says it is not exempt
When in Doubt, Ask What It Is — Not How Big the Building Is
  1. Does it cool the air directly — a rooftop unit, split system, heat pump, or PTAC? EPA puts it in the exempt subsector.
  2. Does it chill water (or another fluid) that then cools the air? That's a chiller — covered at 10% if it holds 15 pounds or more of a covered refrigerant.
  3. Does it refrigerate product or serve a process? It isn't air conditioning at all; it's judged at 20%, 30%, or the 10% catch-all.

The genuinely open cases are large VRF systems, rooftop arrays serving large buildings, and units that mostly serve a process. There, keeping the leak-rate records costs you minutes and is the cautious choice until EPA says more.

Why This Matters for Small Contractors

If your business is mostly air conditioning — residential and commercial alike — most of that work is outside § 84.106. The splits, heat pumps, mini-splits, and rooftop units that fill your service calls don't require leak rate calculations, 30-day repair timelines, or chronic leaker tracking under this rule.

That's genuinely good news. Subpart C's leak-repair section is not a burden on every service call you run.

Where it does reach a small shop is refrigeration and chillers: the walk-in cooler and freezer behind the restaurant, the reach-ins and display cases at the convenience store, the rack at the grocer, the chiller in the office building. At 15 pounds or more of a covered refrigerant, those need the full § 84.106 treatment.

The risk isn't in your air-conditioning work. It's in the refrigeration you service alongside it.

The Other Exemption: ODS-Only Systems

While we're clarifying coverage, there's a second exemption worth noting. Section 84.106(a)(3)(i) exempts appliances that contain solely an ozone-depleting substance (ODS) as a refrigerant.

Systems running only R-22, R-12, or other Class I or Class II ODS refrigerants are covered under the older Section 608 rules (40 CFR Part 82, Subpart F) — not Subpart C. Those systems have their own leak repair requirements with a 50-pound threshold (§ 82.157).

This matters because there are still R-22 systems in the field, and they operate under different rules than the HFC systems covered by Subpart C. If a system runs R-22 and nothing else, Subpart C doesn't apply to it. If a system has been retrofitted to an HFC blend (like R-407C or R-422D), it falls under Subpart C — unless it is a rooftop unit, split system, or other appliance in the exempt residential and light commercial subsector.

One wrinkle: the Section 608 leak-repair rule has no residential or light commercial exemption — EPA's fact sheet puts it plainly: "There are no exemptions for appliances with a charge size of 50 pounds or more of an applicable refrigerant." An R-22 rooftop unit holding 50 pounds or more is still under § 82.157, even though the same unit charged with R-410A would sit in Subpart C's exempt subsector.

RefrigerantLeak-repair ruleCharge threshold
R-22 (ODS only)Section 608 (§ 82.157)50 lbs
R-410A (HFC)Subpart C (§ 84.106)15 lbs
R-404A (HFC)Subpart C (§ 84.106)15 lbs
R-407C (HFC blend, often a retrofit from R-22)Subpart C (§ 84.106)15 lbs
R-134a (HFC)Subpart C (§ 84.106)15 lbs

Subpart C's 15-pound line applies only to appliances outside the residential and light commercial subsector.

GWP Threshold: 53

Subpart C's leak-repair section applies to refrigerants that contain an HFC listed as a regulated substance — whatever the blend's GWP — and to substitutes with a Global Warming Potential greater than 53 (§ 84.106(a)(1)–(2)). That covers essentially all common HFC refrigerants (R-410A at GWP 2,088; R-404A at GWP 3,922; R-134a at GWP 1,430). It does not cover natural refrigerants like CO₂ (R-744, GWP 1), ammonia (R-717, GWP 1), or propane (R-290, GWP 3.3) — the values in table 1 of § 84.64(b). For practical purposes: if it contains a listed HFC, Subpart C's refrigerant test is met and the appliance test still decides. If it's solely an ODS, it's under Section 608. If it's a natural refrigerant, or a low-GWP HFO or HCFO with no listed HFC (R-1234ze(E), R-1233zd(E), R-514A), neither leak-repair rule applies.

A Decision Framework for the Field

Here's a quick-reference flowchart your techs can use to determine whether a system is covered by Subpart C:

Step 1: What refrigerant is in the system?

  • ODS only (R-22, R-12, etc.) → Not Subpart C (covered by Section 608 at the 50-lb threshold)
  • Contains a listed HFC (or is a substitute with GWP > 53) → Continue to Step 2
  • No listed HFC and a GWP of 53 or less — natural refrigerants (CO₂, ammonia, propane) and low-GWP HFOs and HCFOs such as R-1234ze(E), R-1233zd(E), R-514A → Not covered by either leak-repair rule

Step 2: How much refrigerant does it hold?

  • Less than 15 pounds → Not covered by § 84.106's leak-repair rules
  • 15 pounds or more → Continue to Step 3

Step 3: What kind of appliance is it?

  • Rooftop unit, split system, heat pump, PTAC, window or portable unit → Exempt (residential and light commercial subsector)
  • Chiller used for comfort cooling, on a covered refrigerant → Covered at 10%
  • Commercial refrigeration (retail food, cold storage) → Covered at 20%
  • Industrial process refrigeration → Covered at 30%
  • Refrigerated transport or any other appliance → Covered at 10%
  • VRF → unsettled; keep the records

Three questions. Ten seconds. Your tech now knows whether this service call triggers Subpart C obligations before they even open the access panel. The same three questions run in our free applicability checker, which cites the paragraph behind each answer.

The exemption covers most of your air conditioning. It doesn't cover your refrigeration or your chillers — and that's where a small shop's Subpart C work actually lives.

What to Do With This Information

Audit your customer list this week. Identify every account with refrigeration or chillers likely to hold 15 pounds or more of a refrigerant containing a listed HFC. Those are your Subpart C accounts.

Train your techs on the three-question framework. Print the decision flowchart above and put it in the truck. Asking "what refrigerant, how much, what kind of appliance" takes seconds and keeps compliance effort where the rule puts it.

Don't over-comply on air conditioning. § 84.106 doesn't require leak-rate records on a rooftop unit or split system. Keep them if a customer wants them — good records never hurt — but don't build your workload around them.

Don't under-comply on refrigeration. The flip side matters more. If you assume "it's just a small restaurant," you're one walk-in away from a compliance gap.


Next Monday, we're wrapping up this initial series with a complete Subpart C reference guide: every threshold, every deadline, every documentation requirement on one page. The kind of thing you print, laminate, and keep in the truck for the rest of the year. See you February 16th.

Track the Appliances the Rule Actually Covers

Add your walk-ins, racks, chillers, and process systems. Ref LeakLog calculates every leak rate against the right threshold and opens the repair clock the moment one crosses it.

Start Your Free Trial

Or see it live in the demo first — no signup needed.

Keep Reading

Stop Guessing. Start Tracking.

Join contractors across the country who use Ref LeakLog to automate EPA compliance and protect their business.