Comfort Cooling, Commercial Refrigeration, or Industrial Process? The § 84.102 Category That Sets Your Leak-Rate Threshold
Every leak rate you calculate gets judged against 10%, 20%, or 30% — and which one depends entirely on which appliance category the unit lands in. Here are the three § 84.102 definitions verbatim, where the common equipment actually falls, and what a misfiled category quietly does to your compliance record.
Before you can tell whether a leak rate is a problem, you have to know what number it's being compared against. And that number isn't a property of the refrigerant, the charge size, or the building. It's a property of the appliance category — one of three buckets defined in 40 CFR § 84.102 — and the category is the very first thing you decide about a piece of equipment when you set it up in a log, a spreadsheet, or a calculator.
Get it right and the rest of the rule runs on rails. Get it wrong and every leak rate on that unit is compared to the wrong threshold — quietly, for as long as the record exists.
This is the reference for making that call. The three definitions verbatim from the current rule text, where the equipment you actually service lands, the handful of edge cases (chillers, ice machines, mixed-use, reefers), and everything else in § 84.106 that keys off the same choice.
An earlier version of this post filed packaged rooftop units and commercial split systems as covered comfort cooling at 10%, on the reasoning that a commercial building puts them past the residential and light commercial exemption. EPA's preamble says otherwise: the exemption follows the kind of appliance and takes in rooftop units and split systems on commercial buildings (89 FR 82718–82719). The table, the worked example, and the classification habits below are corrected. We also corrected what the 120-day repair window turns on (an industrial process shutdown, not the category), added the exemption as the first step of the ten-second version, and tied the 365-day substitution to the first calculation after January 1, 2026.
The worked example applied the first-calculation substitution in § 84.106(b)(1) without its condition. EPA's preamble limits that: the method "is only allowed when previous records are absent" (89 FR 82724). If you have records of additions before 2026, use them. The example now says the unit had no earlier addition on record. A full re-check of the post the same day also corrected: a rooftop array serving a large building is now among the unsettled cases; a process chiller is industrial process refrigeration only if it is one of the "complex customized" appliances the definition describes; the applicability test, the TRU status and the basis for the 30% rate are now stated as the rule and EPA state them; and the demo is described as a sample fleet.
The Three Thresholds — and the Catch-All
Start with the numbers, because they're the reason the category matters. Under § 84.106(c)(2), the leak rate that triggers repair obligations is:
(i) 20 percent leak rate for commercial refrigeration appliances;
(ii) 30 percent leak rate for industrial process refrigeration appliances; and
(iii) 10 percent leak rate for comfort cooling appliances, refrigerated transport appliances, or other refrigerant-containing appliances with a full charge of 15 or more pounds of refrigerant not covered by paragraph (c)(2)(i) or (ii) of this section.
Read (iii) carefully, because its wording is the single most useful thing in this post. The 10% bucket is the default. An appliance doesn't have to qualify as comfort cooling to get the 10% threshold — it gets 10% unless it fits the definition of commercial refrigeration or industrial process refrigeration. Comfort cooling, refrigerated transport, and "other" all land in the same place. So the classification question is really only two questions: does this appliance meet the commercial refrigeration definition? and does it meet the industrial process refrigeration definition? If the answer to both is no, the threshold is 10% and it does not matter what else you call it.
That framing matters for the leak-rate math because the two higher buckets are privileges you have to earn by fitting a definition — not labels you can pick because they're more forgiving.
The Definitions, Verbatim
All three terms are defined in § 84.102. Here is the current text — pulled from the eCFR as it stands today, not paraphrased.
Comfort cooling — 10%
"Comfort cooling means the refrigerant-containing appliances used for air conditioning to provide cooling in order to control heat and/or humidity in occupied facilities including but not limited to residential, office, and commercial buildings. Comfort cooling appliances include but are not limited to chillers, commercial split systems, dual-function heat pumps, and packaged roof-top units."
The test is the purpose: air conditioning for people in a building. The definition names the equipment most small contractors service all day — packaged rooftop units, commercial split systems, heat pumps — and it names chillers, which is where a lot of misfiling starts (more on that below).
One thing to keep straight: the definition of comfort cooling includes residential systems, but § 84.106(a)(3)(ii) then exempts appliances "used for the residential and light commercial air conditioning and heat pump subsector" from the leak-repair rule entirely. And EPA's preamble says that subsector follows the kind of appliance — it takes in packaged rooftop units, split systems, and heat pumps on commercial buildings too (89 FR 82718–82719). So most of the equipment this definition names is exempt, and covered comfort cooling is, in practice, the chiller. (Three cases stay open: VRF, where EPA's own documents disagree; a rooftop array serving a large building, since EPA describes the subsector as cooling "individual rooms, single-family homes, and small commercial buildings" and lists only some rooftop air conditioning in it (89 FR 82717); and a unit that mostly serves a process, which can be industrial process refrigeration under the 50% test.) We drew that line in detail here; this post assumes the appliance is already past it.
Commercial refrigeration — 20%
"Commercial refrigeration means the refrigerant-containing appliances used in the retail food and cold storage warehouse subsectors. Retail food appliances include the refrigerant-containing appliances found in supermarkets, convenience stores, restaurants, and other food service establishments. Cold storage includes the refrigerant-containing appliances used to store meat, produce, dairy products, and other perishable goods."
This one is defined by sector, not by equipment type or by the word "commercial." A refrigeration appliance in a supermarket, convenience store, restaurant, food-service operation, or a cold-storage warehouse holding perishables is commercial refrigeration. That's the definition that catches walk-ins, cases, and racks — but notice what it does not say. It doesn't say "any refrigeration appliance owned by a business." A refrigeration appliance that isn't in the retail-food or cold-storage-warehouse subsector doesn't get 20% by being non-residential; absent an IPR fit, it falls back to the 10% catch-all.
Industrial process refrigeration — 30%
"Industrial process refrigeration means complex customized refrigerant-containing appliances that are directly linked to the processes used in, for example, the chemical, pharmaceutical, petrochemical, and manufacturing industries. This sector also includes industrial ice machines, appliances used directly in the generation of electricity, and ice rinks. Where one appliance is used for both industrial process refrigeration and other applications, it will be considered industrial process refrigeration equipment if 50 percent or more of its operating capacity is used for industrial process refrigeration."
Three things to pull out of that. First, the words "complex customized" and "directly linked to the processes" — IPR is refrigeration that is part of making something, not refrigeration that happens to be located at a factory. Second, the definition names its outliers: industrial ice machines, power-generation cooling, and ice rinks are IPR by name, even though none of them is a chemical plant. Third, the 50 percent rule for mixed-use appliances — the only place in the three definitions where the rule tells you how to break a tie.
Where the Common Equipment Actually Lands
Applying the definitions to the equipment a small shop or a building owner actually has:
| Appliance | Category | Threshold | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Packaged rooftop unit on a strip mall, small office, or restaurant | Exempt | — | Named in the comfort cooling definition, but EPA places packaged rooftop units in the residential and light commercial subsector § 84.106(a)(3)(ii) exempts at any charge (89 FR 82718) |
| Commercial split system serving offices | Exempt | — | Split systems are in the same exempt subsector (89 FR 82718) |
| Water- or air-cooled chiller conditioning a building | Comfort cooling | 10% | "Chillers" are named in the comfort cooling definition; the purpose is heat/humidity control for occupants |
| Chiller cooling a manufacturing process line | Industrial process refrigeration | 30% | Only if it is one of the "complex customized" appliances "directly linked to the processes used in … manufacturing"; otherwise the 10% catch-all |
| Walk-in cooler or freezer at a restaurant or grocery | Commercial refrigeration | 20% | Retail food subsector |
| Supermarket parallel rack | Commercial refrigeration | 20% | Retail food subsector (and at ≥500 lb, quarterly inspections after an exceedance) |
| Cold-storage warehouse system holding produce or meat | Commercial refrigeration | 20% | Cold storage subsector, named explicitly |
| Ice rink | Industrial process refrigeration | 30% | Named in the IPR definition |
| Industrial ice machine | Industrial process refrigeration | 30% | Named in the IPR definition |
| Refrigerated trailer or container (≥15 lb) | "Refrigerated transport" — the (c)(2)(iii) bucket | 10% | Listed alongside comfort cooling in the 10% paragraph; see the note on the pending rule below |
| Residential or light-commercial split system / heat pump | Exempt | — | § 84.106(a)(3)(ii) — outside the leak-repair rule regardless of charge |
A few of these deserve a closer look.
The chiller problem
"Chiller" is the word most likely to be misfiled, because contractors hear it and think "industrial." The rule doesn't. A chiller whose job is conditioning air for people — the water-cooled centrifugal in a hospital basement, the air-cooled scroll on an office building — is comfort cooling at 10%, because that's the purpose the comfort cooling definition describes and "chillers" is the first item in its equipment list. A chiller cooling a process fluid on a plant floor is IPR at 30% only if it is one of the "complex customized" appliances the IPR definition describes; a standard packaged model may not be, and then it falls to the 10% catch-all. What makes a chiller comfort cooling is the application, not the machine, and a chiller filed as IPR when it's really comfort cooling has a threshold three times looser than the law gives it. That's the classic misfile, and it's an easy one to make on the R-134a calculator if you pick the category by the equipment name.
Ice machines: "industrial" is doing real work
The IPR definition says industrial ice machines. The under-counter cuber behind a restaurant bar is a retail-food appliance — and, at a few pounds of charge, almost never over the 15-lb line in the first place. Don't let the phrase "ice machine" pull small commercial equipment into the 30% bucket.
Mixed use: the 50 percent test
If one appliance does both process cooling and something else — say a chiller loop that serves a production process and the office space next to it — the rule gives you the tiebreaker: it's IPR "if 50 percent or more of its operating capacity is used for industrial process refrigeration." Document the split. This is the one place where your category determination should carry a number.
Reefers and the rule that hasn't landed
Refrigerated transport isn't separately defined in § 84.102, but § 84.106(c)(2)(iii) names "refrigerated transport appliances" in the 10% bucket — so a covered reefer is judged at 10%, same as comfort cooling. Two honest caveats. First, whether a given trailer or container unit is covered runs through the same 15-pound applicability test as everything else: 15 pounds or more of a refrigerant containing an HFC, or of a substitute with a GWP above 53 (§ 84.106(a)). Second, EPA published a proposed rule on May 26, 2026 (91 FR 30532) that would remove road and intermodal-container transport refrigeration units from the leak-repair requirements entirely. As of this writing it is still a proposal — the Federal Register lists it as a proposed rule with no final action — so today's rule is unchanged: 10%, covered. The proposal doesn't reach TRUs on railcars, though EPA asked for comment on them. And EPA's FAQ says that, for § 84.106, it "generally presumes road and intermodal TRUs have a charge size of 15 pounds or less and intends to implement this provision consistent with this presumption" — while the proposal itself says those units are "routinely designed for and/or charged with more than 15 pounds" (91 FR 30536). If any of that changes, we'll write it up.
The equipment form offers four buckets — Comfort Cooling (10%), Commercial Refrigeration (20%), Industrial Process (30%), and Transport Refrigeration (10%). The fourth exists so a reefer is filed as what it is, not mislabeled as an air conditioner — but the engine judges it at 10%, exactly as § 84.106(c)(2)(iii) does. Every calculator on our /tools pages uses the same three thresholds.
The Category Decides More Than the Threshold
If the leak-rate threshold were the only thing riding on the category, a misfile would be one wrong comparison. It isn't. The same classification decides several other clocks and duties in Subpart C, most of them keyed to "industrial process refrigeration" or "commercial refrigeration" by name, and two to whether an industrial process has to shut down:
- The repair clock, § 84.106(d). Leaks must be identified and repaired "within 30 days (or 120 days if an industrial process shutdown is required)." The 120-day alternative turns on the repair, not the category: it applies only when an industrial process shutdown is required to make it — in practice, mostly process equipment — and the rest of the repair workflow is the same. A building chiller or a supermarket rack gets 30 days.
- Extensions, § 84.106(f). The parts-availability extension caps at 180 days from the exceedance — "or 270 days if an industrial process shutdown is required." Same condition, same asymmetry.
- The post-repair inspection schedule, § 84.106(g)(1). Quarterly inspections after an exceedance apply only to "commercial refrigeration and industrial process refrigeration appliances with a full charge of 500 or more pounds." Comfort cooling and everything else is annual at any charge size. A 90-lb lab freezer and a 900-lb chiller are both annual; a 500-lb supermarket rack is quarterly.
- Automatic leak detection, § 84.108. The ALD mandate at 1,500 pounds or more applies to appliances "used for industrial process refrigeration or commercial refrigeration." A 1,500-lb comfort cooling chiller isn't in it.
- "Custom-built," § 84.102. The definition that unlocks certain retrofit/retirement timing is written for "industrial process refrigeration equipment or any of its components" — it doesn't exist for the other two categories.
Notice the pattern: the rule gives process equipment the 30% threshold and custom-built timing by category, and the 120-day clock and 270-day extension cap when a process has to shut down for the repair. EPA set the 30% rate on costs and benefits (81 FR 82319; kept for Part 84 on similar factors, 89 FR 82729) and tied the longer repair windows to an industrial process shutdown and "the complexity of adequately repairing" process systems (89 FR 82727). Filing a comfort-cooling chiller as IPR doesn't just loosen the threshold; it hands that appliance a set of allowances the rule never intended for it. An inspector reading a 120-day repair record on a building chiller isn't going to see a paperwork slip. They're going to see a threshold and a deadline that are both wrong in the same direction, and an inspection schedule set by the wrong category.
What a Misfile Actually Does to the Record
Take an ordinary service call: a walk-in cooler at a medical laboratory, with an 18-lb full charge of R-404A, takes 3 pounds — its first addition since January 1, 2026, with no earlier addition on record. Annualized on the first-calculation rule (§ 84.106(b)(1); 89 FR 82724), that's 16.7%.
Filed correctly — a lab is neither retail food nor cold storage, so its walk-in falls in the rule's 10% catch-all (§ 84.106(c)(2)(iii)) — that unit just tripped the threshold: a 30-day repair clock starts, an initial and follow-up verification test are owed, and an annual inspection schedule follows. Misfiled as commercial refrigeration — because a walk-in looks like the one behind every restaurant — the same 16.7% reads as under 20%, no repair action is created, and no clock starts. Nothing in the record looks wrong. The rate was calculated with an approved method, the addition was logged, the ticket has all eight § 84.106(l)(2) fields. It's just being judged against a threshold that doesn't apply, and the 30-day deadline the rule started on the day of that addition passes without anyone knowing it existed.
The reverse misfile is less dangerous and more expensive: a walk-in filed as comfort cooling gets held to 10% instead of 20% and generates repair actions the rule doesn't require. That costs you labor and customer patience, not a violation — but it also teaches the shop to distrust the numbers, which is how real exceedances start getting waved off.
The leak-rate math can be perfect and the record still wrong. The category is the one input that changes what "over" means.
Write the Determination Down
The recordkeeping paragraph, § 84.106(l), doesn't list "appliance category" as a required field — the per-appliance file under (l)(1) asks for the full charge, its method, revisions, location, and installation date, and the service record under (l)(2) asks for the leak rate and the method used to determine it. But the leak rate is only meaningful against a threshold, and the threshold comes from the category. If your file shows a 16.7% leak rate and no repair action, the first question is "what did you compare it to, and why?" A one-line category determination on the appliance record — with the reason, and the capacity split for anything mixed-use — is how you answer that in five seconds instead of an afternoon.
Two more habits that keep this clean:
Classify per appliance, not per site. A restaurant has commercial refrigeration in the kitchen and air conditioning on the roof — which, as a rooftop unit, sits in the exempt subsector. A plant has IPR on the process line and comfort cooling in the front office. The building's business tells you what to look for; it doesn't set the category of every unit inside it. And remember that under § 84.102, an appliance with multiple independent refrigerant circuits is counted as a separate appliance per circuit — each one gets its own category and its own full charge.
Classify by purpose, then check the named list. Ask what the appliance is for — people, food, or process — and then check whether the definition names it outright (chillers, ice rinks, industrial ice machines). For air conditioning, check the exemption first: EPA puts rooftop units, split systems, and heat pumps in the exempt subsector. When purpose and name seem to disagree, purpose wins for chillers (the definition puts them under comfort cooling because of the purpose) and the named list wins for the IPR outliers (ice rinks are IPR because the rule says so).
If you still service R-22 equipment under the older Section 608 leak-repair rules in 40 CFR Part 82, the category logic carries over: § 82.152 defines "comfort cooling," "commercial refrigeration," and "industrial process refrigeration" in nearly identical language, including the 50 percent mixed-use test. One classification habit serves both rules.
The Ten-Second Version
- Is it air conditioning that cools the air directly — a rooftop unit, split system, heat pump, or PTAC? → By EPA's description that's the residential and light commercial subsector, exempt from § 84.106 at any charge. Stop here — unless it's VRF (EPA's documents disagree), it's part of a rooftop array serving a large building (EPA hasn't placed it), or it mostly serves a process.
- Is it in the retail food or cold storage warehouse subsector? Supermarket, convenience store, restaurant, food service, or a warehouse holding perishables → commercial refrigeration, 20%.
- Is it complex, customized, and directly linked to a manufacturing/chemical/pharma/petrochemical process — or an ice rink, industrial ice machine, or power-generation cooling? → Industrial process refrigeration, 30%. Mixed use: 50% or more of capacity on the process.
- Neither? → 10%. Comfort cooling (in practice, chillers), transport, or "other" — the threshold is the same.
Make that call once, at setup, in writing. Every leak rate the appliance ever generates is judged by it.
Set the category once — the engine holds the right threshold forever
Ref LeakLog files every appliance as comfort cooling, commercial refrigeration, industrial process, or transport at setup, then judges every service event against the § 84.106(c)(2) threshold that category carries — 10%, 20%, or 30% — and starts the 30-day clock (120 days when an industrial process shutdown is required) the moment one trips. See it run on the demo's sample fleet, or start your own file.
Start Your Free TrialOr see it live in the demo first — no signup needed.